Zha vs z2m reddit. ZHA is a built-in integration, and quite intuitive to use.

Zha vs z2m reddit I recently started with HA, and have abt 15 hue/ikea lights all managed by the Hue Bridge. ZHA is not bad, but Z2M is a godsend. It works well and has support for everything I've ever come across. Systematic changes after that: frequency is first, dongle is second, software is last -- if ZHA vs MQTT solves the problem in the end, I would keep seking another solution to your problem, im not saying its impossible but. First turn deconz in pairing mode from phoscon control panel/website. For some reason it can’t locate the coordinator, tho it could just be my Proxmox setup. I have tons of Xiaomi Aqara sensors (motion, temperature, and door/window) paired directly to my HUSBZB-1 without the Xiaomi hub. I installed a second Zigbee Dongle to run Z2M in parallel to ZHA. This is pretty straight forward in Z2M but it doesn't seem to be that simple with ZHA, if possible at all. Anyway, did you go with the "Coordinator - USB - Raspberry Pi with Z2M - MQTT - HA" solution? Does it work well? Edit: Another alternative is apparently to use something like ser2net, as ZHA has builtin support for Serial-over-IP connection to its coordinator. I've moved everything to Channel 25, made sure my wifi is only on channels 1 and 6 as well as tried other coordinators in the past with mixed results. Curious if there’s an advantage to installing it with Docker and passing to Mosquitto broker, or if I should just install the Z2M add on, which appears to be turn-key. The plan is to build a forced induction shop car for air strip roll racing and… No, the laptop I'm using is dedicated to home assistant (haos). Then hold middle button from the 3 gang switches. Haven’t had any major issues with ZHA, but setting up with Z2M is a different story. (Enabled the z2m web gui frontend and it’s really nice) The one thing that I didn’t know and I want to warn you: if you use node red for your automations, ZHA is infinitely easier as it adds a whole bunch of useful nodes that you won’t have if you want to connect NR directly to mqtt or z2m Even though other lidl devices like their smart lamps were working fine with ZHA. It's basically a timer which resets every time the device pings the coordinator. I've heard anecdotes that Z2M is faster. However, I would choose Z2M over ZHA any day of the week. I test and review devices for a blog and never have I encountered a product working better in ZHA over Z2M. Obviously that's a short-term issue at worst since both zha and z2m are pretty good about picking up new device support quickly. I had a nightmare in the beginning. I'll look into it again in a year or two. Currently I am using ZigBee+ZHA but I have heard so many times that zigbee2mqtt is much superior. But if you are starting out (like you would be), use Z2M. 0 USB Dongle Plus (EFR32MG21) instead of a Conbee II. Yes it works fine with both ZHA and Z2M. These devices go to sleep. Tubes does offer dedicated router devices that dont' need network access as they connect to the ZigBee network and act as a router on the Zigbee network. ZHA did not let me rename entities which made NodeRED a pita to configure and recognize devices and, last but not least, a fair amount of devices in my home network aren't supported by ZHA while z2m does, flawlessly So, no, no ZHA for me anymore. Similar to the current Zwave implementation, Z2M is detached from Home Assistant so reboots don't affect it. Both have some OTA support, z2m is probably better, but the latest zha toolkit can now use the z2m OTA repository, leveling the playing field, even if not fully GUI integrated. The SLZB-06(m) itself works just fine in both ZHA and Z2M. One things that actually worked was the fan switch– even though it was identified as a light, I could change the speed with a corresponding dimmer value. Here’s, a great comparison guide which may help you decide which one is best for you. In addition, I'm running a separate Z2M for an individual room with ~20 devices (IKEA, Hue, Xaomi, OSRAM) which are working 100% reliable since years with a zzh CC2652R coordinator. I did this about a month after setting up HA. I used ZHA for about a year and recently switched to ZIgbee2MQTT. Having suffered from issues debugging my Zigbee devices in the past I'd really give this a shot. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest Weirdly stable device, it seems Tuya is aiming for Zigbee stack compatibility with their Z2 series modules. I followed the manual. 2, w/ flow control) flashed MultiPAN RCP firmware and it works perfectly for my 50+ node system in ZHA I came from a CC2652P in Z2M, but I wanted to be ‘ready’ for Matter and was looking to simplify my setup as I didn’t have anything that required Z2M in play Jun 21, 2022 · I wound up using the two ITead Sonoff ZBDonglesx—one E and one P. Not a single time has ZHA had better support for a device over Z2M. Things were always running and more stable. But that is what you should investigate. Aug 30, 2022 · ZHA vs Z2M. I am using Conbee II stick, and HomeAssistant is running on top of Proxmox/Docker. Same goes for Z2M. They've been working great with Z2M, though I did need to manually adjust their reporting config within Z2M to get them to work at all. The great integration into Home Assistant makes installation and device discovery really really simple. I went back to the Hue hub after trying ZHA and Z2M with the Conbee II dongle. It's still pretty straightforward, but I find the interface for Z2M to be more advanced/technical and you do often have access to more entities, so I prefer it. Any large cons to switch all my lights over to Z2M? Main benefit for me would be the far beter mesh network coverage. Good luck change the documentation that doesn't put the default direction in a positive light. The process was as follows: For every integration or add-on, I had to start with a fresh Home Assistant installation and then I installed the integration or add-on so ZHA or Zigbee2MQTT or deCONZ. A Z2M group with the same lights would be a single call from HA to Z2M. I know I’ll have to go and repair the devices so I made a spreadsheet with the device names and the entity names used in automations. I decided to change the coordinator to Conbee II and switch HA from Raspberry Pi to regular PC server running HA (docker), Z2M (docker), Mosquitto (bare metal) and some minor network services (like: local DNS and DHCP) under Linux. There is a trick to get them working in ZHA though! You can only have one coordinator which is the main radio that the software ZHA or Z2M (or there is others) that connect to. I use a ~$10 Easyiot ZB-GW04 (v1. Aug 15, 2024 · I’d like to share my experience in choosing between Zigbee2MQTT (Z2M) and Zigbee Home Automation (ZHA) on Home Assistant (HA). But these days not as much the case anymore, they're mostly different in setup. I would recommend DeConz or ZHA, do your own research on why you should choose the one over the other, also do some research on Z2M. I moved from ZHA to Z2M because some of my Aqara double switches kept flaking out with the former. Z2M. If you decide half way through you want to go back to zha, you’ll still have to reconfigure all your devices. Someone could create a quirk to handle it until it's supported but that's above me I'm afraid Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. To migrate from one to the other, I simply put Z2M into "permit join" mode, then went to each ZigBee device one by one and put them into pairing mode. Can't say I know how it works in ZHA but I assume it's similar. So there may be more work to be done before going the other way. My brother was a ZHA adopter from the off, then moved to z2m. I will just wait it out until someone much smarter than me gets them going on Z2M. But I didn’t find any specifics, no proof, no solution. I have the Sonoff dongle-E, some sonoff s40 zigbee plugs and aqara water leak and temperature sensors. I ordered the third reality. I bought E in december and started using ZHA. Sonoff WiFi Bridges. That is EACTLY why I tried ZHA first vs Z2M, however I immediately ran into small issues trying to do more advanced things, like DIRECT bind my IKEA remotes to my IKEA blinds which where flaky and lacked feedback in ZHA but worked great in Z2M. In HA, the group sends a call to the coordinator for each device in that group. Tuya 5ghz is the only one supported under ZHA, both are supported under Z2M Tuya 24Ghz has more options and is a little better at distance, but both work great. I’m actually looking to move to Z2M from ZHA, I tried deleting the ZHA integration and installing Z2M through the supervisor panel but I’m getting some weirdness. ZHA is a built-in integration, and quite intuitive to use. Z2M provides more information than ZHA, so for that project it's a no-brainer. However so far i have only heard its possible to go fr z2m to zha. They could spend the ZHA development resources elsewhere instead of trying to reinvent the wheel. Okee two questions, i am running HASS with a Conbee II stick and i use ZHA. I would like to migrate away from the Hue Bridges. It also has slightly better device support in my experience. The key is having Z2M in pairing mode. ZHA is (even) easier to set up, Z2M has more knobs and dials, a dedicated GUI that makes it a little easier to manage, and I like being able to monitor everything via MQTT for debugging and troubleshooting. Under Z2M, the only difference I see is that the LQI values are more realistic with the Sonoff (there is/was a big where the Conbee II was adding LQIs together or something making almost all devices show 255 all the time). The pros for Z2M are that it's going to support a wider range of devices, and give you better control of them. So this likely isn't helpful but I would abandon ZHA and go with Zigbee2MQttt. ZHA integration was finding Conbee II just fine. So depending on how you're planning on using your Zigbee radio (ZHA vs. Most posts mention the Docker implementation of Z2M. What cemented my choice was the "decoupled factor" I like to tinker. I’m currently on Zha. I have deleted ZHA, installed Mosquitto integration (seems to be running fine), added Z2M repository and installed Z2M. So a group in HA that has 10 lights, is 10 calls to Z2M. The nice thing about them is they publish their firmware updates via OTA so you can update through both Z2M and ZHA via their respective UI's. I suggest you pair a couple devices to zha, play around a bit, then remove it and pair a couple devices with z2m and play around a bit. In my case it seems ZHA is more stable and responsive. Bulbs in a Zigbee group seem to change all at once vs Sequentially in an HA Group. ZHA is configured via the Home Assistant dashboard without having to wrestle with any YAML. I have a working ZHA setup on a RPi4, Cc2531, ~25 zigbee devices, IKEA, Philips, tuya, standard stuff. I recently switched from ZHA to z2m due to a plethora of issues with ZHA. I'd try rebooting your HA host device, reseating the dongle, etc. More importantly, z2m config is stored in yaml, making hardware migration a breeze. I am migrating from zha to z2m so obviously this half baked info is a thorn in my side. Having it in MQTT makes it possible to integrate other projects that aren't HA. Reply reply I started with ZHA. they are both great. I already had a ZigBee mesh with SmartThings that I rebuilt in ZHA, and, yes, you have to rebuild it again when you move to Z2M. Nov 27, 2023 · Z2M supports more devices than ZHA, but I’m sure you can find a few exceptions. Remove the device from ZHA while Z2M is in pairing mode. Adding devices is super easy too. To be honest, I think most people tend to decide between ZHA and Zigbee2mqtt (which you will see abbreviated as Z2M). That was my clue that ZHA was the problem, not the conbee necessarily. Also he is telling me i should a Sonoff ZigBee 3. They have different functions and the preference will be different per user. I would personally go with the Sonoff P - currently have the CC2652RB and that's running nicely. I’m running the HASS VM (in Proxmox). But since i switched to ZHA + Sonoff E (tried different FW versions) my HUE motion sensors keep dropping off. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; &nbsp; TOPICS ZHA vs Z2M upvotes I have a bunch of smart plugs from them that we use for holiday decorations and they work fine. Does anybody know what could lead Z2M to overwrite the ZHA settings? Both dongles are Sonoff ZBDongle-P. Neither z2m nor zha is better than the other, and for the most part it comes down to personal preference unless you have a zigbee device that doesn't work well/at all with one or the other. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; &nbsp; TOPICS ZHA vs Z2M upvotes I posted about the Routers I made the other day these were an offshoot of the coordinator work. In parallel, I will have at least one Z-wave device (smart lock); possibly more in the future. Go read some of the dev threads about why they didn't opt for ZWaveJS2MQTT (now known as ZWave JS UI) and then take a look at the pros/cons section of that documentation. I'm having issues where my menu is full of dead clicks and the game selection… Jan 25, 2021 · There are two awesome tools for local control over Zigbee devices: ZHA vs Zigbee2Mqtt. I have since noticed that the ZHA screenshot on this page shows a Quirk installed which might be adding the functionality. You will then need to remove zha and go through and rename your entities from mqtt to match exactly what you had in zha otherwise you will need to redo all your automations etc. zigbee map was a mess with many isolated devices, not responding after a few hours etc. I'm using a custom ZHA integration (zha-new) to do it, but I've been told that recent versions of the built in ZHA work just as good and don't require the hub either. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. While browsing during commute I found a few posts here and there that zigbee2mqtt seems to somehow drain end device batteries faster than zha. I have migrated most of my automations and scenes (as scripts) and really enjoying the added features and control I can have now. ZHA turned out to cause issues (kept crashing my HA) and now the integration still shows up even after removal so it left some remnants. Maybe a bit of FOMO :stuck_out_tongue: So i was also thinking about swithing to Z2M for a while. Anyway. I had some issues with Z2M that is a bit weird and I can't figure out if it's my hardware(rpi3+ 1GB). I noticed zero difference in latency, everything was basically instant before and after. The main motivation would be to get rid of the Hue Bridges and to improve stability. After restoring the backup, ZHA is back to normal. mostly because I was waiting on the ethernet ESP32 boards for the coordinators to come in. I just switched from ZHA to Z2M and I definitely like it more. It's just personal preference of interface, and client device support. 0 plus dongle. Now I'm running the Sonoff usb v2 dongle with Z2M and it works like a dream. Migrated from a Conbee II running Z2M to Skyconnect running ZHA. However I paired an AliExpress "tuya" human presence sensor with it and ZHA didn't see any entities from it. In Z2M you listen to the event as a trigger for the automation, it's not a seperate entity or an attribute of the device. Zigbee possibilities also differ: ZHA is pretty young still, is part of HA, and has a fraction of devices support comparing to Z2M. Candidly if your going to get a new dongle, putting that on ZHA might make sense. Also looking at confirmed device support Z2M just had FAR wider device support. When it comes to device support and stability I have had 0 problems with ZHA the past 3 years but others have reported some issues with chinese devices that don't 100% follow the zigbee spec. I did end up using Z2M with this so I could keep ZHA for a subset of my devices. This gave me the push to switch to Z2M which worked perfectly straight away. If, however, you have device that works with Z2M and not fully with ZHA, then it's an easy fix to migrate. Here I will show you how to set up ZHA with Home Assistant and compare ZHA and Zigbee2MQTT. However, I'm now looking to get off deCONZ, and one thing I like behind Zigbee2mqtt is the separation of Zigbee from HA. Just curios cause I found an article that says: "After switching to ZHA, I can definitely confirm that the SkyConnect with Z2M does not run half as well, as fast or as far as it does with ZHA! The improvement in LQI mentioned in the video is apparently simply a display or calculation problem!" Apr 10, 2022 · The process to compare Zigbee2MQTT vs ZHA vs deCONZ. Z2M was also not compatible with one device, but I learned I could add it using translator. I’m wondering if it’s because of the ZHA, should I be using Z2M as some say should be better. The Hue hub was always rock solid with my Hue lights and sensors and the Philips sensors are top quality so I will stick to them as much as possible. Clusters missing is a ZHA thing. On a few devices, I had to press the joining button for them to join, but most of them (mostly Jasco Switches) came over on their own as soon as I removed them. Will see how it goes Now I'm looking to switch to Zigbee2MQTT as a few devices I want are not supported by ZHA. From ZHA to Z2M . In Phoscon I'd have to search event logs and set up automations for something like 'on zha_event id 4953' if I wanted an event when a Xiami Cube is shaken. Or check it out in the app stores ZHA vs z2m upvotes Top Posts Reddit . No text configuration needed in most cases, just the GUI. Interested in switching from ZHA to Zigbee2MQTT. It supports more devices, gives you more control, let's you put your coordinator wherever you want (not just where HA is), and gives you more independence from HA, if you ever need it. When it comes to ZHA vs Z2M there isn't really much of a functional difference. Someone is telling me Zigbee2MQTT is better. I can force devices to join specific routers/repeaters if I want. ZHA setup would be much simpler given its a default integration for HA. Mine is the other way around, before I'm using Z2M and switched to ZHA. Hubs were in the exact same place as the skyconnect is now, and worked fine. I tried pairing them to ZHA but failed. My ikea buttons randomly break in zha. I’ll start Z2M, try and go to the web UI, it shows nothing, then I go back to supervisor and Z2M has stopped. But it's pretty much the same story with Z2M, sometimes a device works better in Z2M sometimes in ZHA. 3 days later, same thing. I have about a dozen zigbee devices connected to HA via ZHA+Conbee II. Edit: my question is maybe too confusing. For me it wasn't just that Z2M supported _more_ devices, it was also how those devices were supported. Which one should you use? I recently switched from Zigbee2MQTT to ZHA. 0 and switched from ZHA to Z2M last summer (mainly for the extra functionality and device support). I was just adding to ZHA to test if they worked. i decided to pickup some ikea bulbs and a bunch of blue inovelli switches and a few motion sensors from ikea. Do I need to remove / disable ZHA before adding the Z2M and parking devices? I'm my personal opinion z2m has the biggest range/variety of supported devices as well as the most support for things like obscure device-specific features and device configuration (timeout on a motion sensor, calibration on a temperature sensor, etc) I think support for TI devices has been added to ZHA fairly recently, so that's a yes. doesn't expose anything useful). Background: I want to use the Freint Electricity Meter Interface (Develco ZHEMI101) and it doesn't seem to work well with ZHA, that's why I'm trying to get Zigbee2MQTT to work. 5 devices on ZHA and 47 on Z2M. Anyways biggest reason will be device support, like when you buy a just releases device it will be first added to Z2M due to the community (had this with the Aqara Thermostats, needed to use the dev version of Z2M) or if you want to use some less popular Tuya stuff. It's a bit larger than the Aqara, and in some areas behind, but presents no issues when pairing with ZHA or Z2M and easily rebuilds paths to the coordinator when it's physical location is changed. While it worked perfectly via Z2M - it depends more on the compatibility of your end devices. Worked well enough for 3 days then stopped. I hear that moving to a new stick will be easier with Z2M? Overall I like the interface of Z2M a lot more than ZHA and I have more control and info about my zigbee network. I know that ZHA is home assistants' internal development and they want to make deployment of HA as simple as possible, but imo they should drop ZHA and instead include Mosquitto and Z2M as defaults. That said, the primary goal here since I'm switching from ZHA to Z2M is figuring out the most efficient way of adding all/many devices. Had a number of Zigbee lockups or unclean starts which messed everything up. r/Garmin is the community to discuss and share everything and anything related to Garmin. In z2m you can adjust the limit. running channel 20 did a wifi scan seemed like that was my best choice ( i have tried a few others though) i cannot get anything Im not saying you are wrong, but Im confused how ZHA vs Z2M could make a difference. This was even worse with devices regularly dropping off and ZHA crashing, so I went back to Z2M as it was slightly more reliable. I needed to move from ZHA to z2m because I needed to move my Homeassistant to a different server and decouple it from the zigbee dongle. The setup was not as easy as ZHA, but is totally doable. From what I understand As for ZHA vs Z2M. OK, will switch to z2m, is it sufficient to disable ZHA or should i remove all the devices from ZHA and then do the new integration to Z2M? If i do backup now and switch to Z2M won't be success, can i have revert the backup and at least ZHA will work ? Will the name of sensor etc remains the same ? Thanks Ran fine. I basically plan to use ZBDongle-P with Z2M (since its still the recommended coordinator) then use ZBDongle-E with ZHA. ZHA: Ease of Use and Home Assistant Integration ZHA is notably easier to use, especially for those who have previously interacted with Zigbee2MQTT. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; &nbsp; TOPICS ZHA vs Z2M upvotes I was looking to do the same thing, but couldn’t get Z2M to work on the Conbee, so I bit the bullet and ordered the Sonoff last night, arriving tomorrow. Z2M, on the other hand, is separate software solution, dedicated to work with Zigbee. Had to physically unplug and reinsert the Skyconnect to get it working again. What happens when it's a Z2M group is it's a single call from the coordinator to the devices. Less overhead in HA itself, however this would seem be offset by additional processing by the zigbee controller. I was wondering if the newest version of Lekmod is compatible with EUI. Especially painful is the good support for Wyze Lock and there are issues on GitHub which require reverse engineering raw bits. In general people seem to prefer Z2M on Reddit due to compatibility with other devices, but my most prized zigbee devices will be these switches so I want to make sure they work well They're both integrations for your ZigBee devices. i was already in 2023. But i read a lot about Sonoff E being “better” so i wanted to give that a try. ) Those two devices get different “generic”mserial port names /dev/ttyUSBn vs /dev/ttyACMn. Most seem to like Z2M more. Side note, I found that doing firmware updates with Z2M is much more reliable than ZHA. Anythin 1-33% was low, 34-66% was Hedium, and 67%+ was high. It does. Sometimes zigbee2mqtt exposes more features of a device. I had to move an IKEA switch to Z2M to get a stronger signal to the part of my home the Parasolls are and now it works reliably. The reason for not trying another integration ZHA or Z2M is the amount of devices and unpairing/pairing again and my HA is running in docker in a ESXi VM. Going to take the plunge from ZHA with a Cone II to Z2M with my new Sonoff I have 60 ZHA devices mostly just aqara sensors. Anyway I have a small quantity of full blown Coordinators available on my store now. I noticed I couldn't make it work while my sonoff zigbee antenna was used by ZHA so I disabled ZHA in the integration's panel. Converting to Zigbee2MQTT Converting between ZHA (built-in Zigbee Home Assistant) and Zigbee2MQTT is a lot more involved, and neither solution is going to 100% solve every issue. Z2M is responsible for the zigbee network and publishes to HA via MQTT. Z2M will expose a couple of entities but I think it's essentially just a single click. deCONZ just worked. Now those few tuya zigbee devices that didn’t play nice with ZHA work flawlessly with z2m. This is the Reddit community for EV owners and enthusiasts. Also it’s a one way ticket. I then started looking more into the device I had. As others have said, check possible interference from Wi-Fi. Of the twelve devices I was adding, two were not compatible with deconz. When I migrated from Nortek ZHA to ZBDongle-P Z2M, I was running both and just put each device in pair mode, added to Z2M, updated my automations with the new entity, then removed from ZHA I am running Z2M using a conbee stick and zha using a sonoff with tasmoda flashed on it because my centrallite thermostats did not play nicely on Z2M but are working beautifully with ZHA in addition to there are slightly different ways there implemented with Z2M giving it a high low set point but did not have auto heat changeover to cooling Z2M is 3rd-party service, managed as add-on (docker container), and integrated to HA through MQTT. I moved from ZHA to Z2M in a similar fashion, I already had a Sonoff dongle-E running ZHA, I bought a Dongle-P which I put to work with Z2M. My general take on the two is here . Getting constant Offline status on my devices mostly Sonoffs and Zemismarts. ZHA (Zigbee Home Automation) is one way of using Zigbee inside HA, Z2M is another. Posted by u/OnlyForSomeThings - 1 vote and no comments In z2m you need to enable "online" reporting for battery devices. I have a second Conbee II stick I connected to my NAS and now run Z2M on it and all Parasoll's connected fine to it. Now, before I moved everything was working fine. mesh looked better, and didn't have issues since then. E is based off a newer chip and works with zha fine but is considered experimental for z2m Reply reply For some reason, when I do it to a Zigbee group created in Z2M, the dimming is kind of janky. ZHA is a newer alternative to Zigbee2MQTT and does a couple of things differently. i had ZHA running, delete all devices, and uninstall ZHA. Join and Discuss evolving technology, new entrants, charging infrastructure, government policy, and the ins and outs of EV ownership right here. I am finally biting the bullet and moving from ZHA integration to Mosquitto/Zigbee2MQTT. 12. Also, in your setup, when you reboot Home Assistant (or reload ZHA) does the Zigbee network stay online (with Z2M running)? If so, it would be an interesting use case — currently my issue is that every time I restart Home Assistant (or reload ZHA), the Zigbee network also restarts and it takes a few hours for all devices to become responsive. Aqara devices seem to be better but that may be due to them liking channel 25 I read somewhere a while back. That being said, it's not like it's difficult. Recommendation: one if the ones that are supported by your zigbee integration of choice (ZHA) vs (Z2M). For example I have an aqara light switch, with ZHA only a single click is registered, but with z2m I also get a double click action. From what I read ZHA is great at what it does, but it's a bit more limited in compatibility and flexibility. We both still remain z2m, and community contributions to z2m are regular via GitHub pull requests having just made one myself for an unsupported bulb. So of those two, that's what I'd recommend. I’ve been running HA Supervisor on a Raspberry Pi 3B+ for a few years now. Everything works fine so far, except after a restart of HA the ZHA Zigbee settings are being overwritten by the Z2M settings. It has a better interface and OTA updates for your things that support it. In Z2M everything comes through as a normal state change like 'shake' or 'rotate90'. Seems to be a tossup in the HA community ZHA vs Zigbee2mqtt. I'd recommend z2m. One is better supported by Z2M, from memory I think it is the non-V2, the TI CC based one. I also have a Sky connect so decided to migrate over to it and ZHA hoping it would make a difference. I am also willing to switch to z2m or Defconz if it helps. This subreddit is an unofficial, non-affiliated community, run by the users, to embrace and have conversation about the products we love! Default ZHA integration exposes just the temperature and no other features (window open detection, external temperature, etc. The funny thing is that comprehensive write-ups are great but nothing replaces experience and learning by doing. At the time I started, I was having problems with getting things working with ZHA and Zigbee2mqtt. Thing is it seems listening to events instead of state changes is a bit trickier in Z2M. The DeConz dongle works with both DeConz and ZHA, so if you are going to try out one of those hubs, buy that stick, since you will be able to try the other, if you are not happy with your first choise. The backup format us supposed to be shared between zha and z2m allowing to migrate between them. then i changed position(in previous position i had a perfectly working conbi 2 stick) and left it there for 2 days. I recently moved from ZHA to zigbee2mqtt. Again. The stick and deconz is right now running on a different, physical machine and can be accessed via network. Z2M will give you a few more diagnostics, but that will depend on if your smart home is a setup and leave alone, or if you are a tinkerer who constantly fiddles with it and has to look at diagnostic graphs all the time. For example, I have zigbee buttons and rotary knobs around the house used to trigger various actions. dont need to exclude/include with zigbee, which made pairing everything again much quicker than Zwave. I've setup a Sonoff Zigbee Bridge (tasmota) with ZHA and also setup a Pi running Z2M with the Sonoff zigbee 3. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. ZHA “just worked” most of the time but when it didn’t, I had no access to information to understand why. Disadvantages Groups are now defined in multiple places if you have a mixture of device types Cannot mix WiFi and Zigbee bulbs in a group. My take on it is here: ZHA Vs Zigbee2Mqtt - #3 by jerrm. reReddit: Top posts of May 9 I’m using it with a Sonoff USB coordinator. zha is a bit more beta feeling in my opinion as well as a bit less configurable, at least from the GUI. Recently I decided to pick up the new Sonoff dongle to see if it worked better than the conbee, and it had all the same problems. They cannot work together unless you run two separate ZigBee networks on separate I have a Sonoff ZigBee stick 3. Posted by u/Complex_Solutions_20 - 1 vote and 7 comments For example, before migrating from ZHA to Z2M : shutdown production homeassistant (you can't have 2 clients using the same serial device) deploy homeassistant and Z2M in a test environment configure Z2M to use my real devices check that everything is fine finally deploy to production Having used both, z2M has seems much more polished if you are using a device in there support list. If the timer is over the limit, the device is marked offline. Personally I started with z2m, then tried moving to ZHA, moved right back to z2m the same afternoon. Hue was running on one channel and ikea on another. I’d recommend getting the dongle, use it to run z2m side by side with ZHA, test a few devices, and then decide where you want to be long term. However, if I create a light group in HA with all the bulbs or just call the service on all the bulbs, I can set the dimming delay really low and get it to be very Nov 23, 2024 · Converting similar tools I recently converted from the native Z-Wave JS to Z-Wave JS UI. In retrospect I’m impressed I learned all of these things over the last eight months and know what it all means in writing and in practice. its not like they can be polled? Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I read it was possible but I have a few questions regarding this approach: Will this approach actually help with my situation of having too many devices? If yes . Odd behavior with blue fan switch - ZHA vs z2m upvotes /r/StableDiffusion is back open after the protest of Reddit killing open API access, which will bankrupt Which zigbee dongle is best mostly looking at SONOFF ZigBee 3. It works flawlessly. I’ve seen mixed things on the forums, some seem to have better UI experiences with ZHA whereas some people seemed to have issues getting things set up with Z2M. Archived post. As I said earlier ZHA works with sonoff dongle, but there are issues with the light switch (aqara e1 double rocker) and aqara switch, that's why I wanted to switch to zigbee2mqtt. Or check it out in the app stores &nbsp; Odd behavior with blue fan switch - ZHA vs z2m Looking at purchasing my 3rd corvette, narrowed down to C7 base M7. I've used both a Conbee II and the Sonoff with ZHA and honestly don't see any difference with the Sonoff. I switched to z2m for the ease in adding "unsupported" devices after getting annoyed having to capture zha_events. somewhere ZHA gives pretty well the same functionality for the devices themselves. ). (The EFR/EZSP v2 support is still experimental in Z2M, but that is fully supported by ZHA. I recently got a motion sensor from them and so far it works advertised. So even several zigbee networks. i have had home assistant running for a few months. I was also thinking about giving ZHA a go, but I've been using z2m for quite a while now and it's been very solid (went from CC2531 to the dev board you linked and recently to zzh! stick). But you cant really go wrong with either. For example, it will start dimming but brighten for a second and then continue to dim. Unsure if it’s the buttons, or zha, that causes the issue. I will probably start caring less about how the MQTT topics are organized, however I kinda like the "<floor>/<room>/<device type>" convention for the friendly names, given how the below image shows. I embarked on the endeavour of installing z2m, took a bit of fiddling around. I've never used zha, so maybe it's just as good but having a layer of abstraction from HA is a good thing in my view. Those devices arent or shouldnt be "listening", and only wake themselves when they periodically check in or if someone pressed the button. I added some end points and devices that weren't updated for ZHA so I had to either go with deconz or Z2M to get them to work. Went back to the Conbee and Z2M for now. The ZHA interface is simple and hides complexity, while ZIgbee2MQTT reveals a lot more info. Other than that, having HA start quicker is a plus (because it doesn't have to wait for ZHA). However, it seems z2m supports WAY less devices than ZHA. Zigbee2MQTT), check out the following: I'm migrating from Zigbee2Mqtt to ZHA and am looking for ways to change device specific settings, for example the timeout value for motion sensors. It seems that some (not sure on the specifics) ZHA users are having no issues with the devices but the vast majority are not working with ZHA due to it not being supported. apologies if i miss anything kinda new to this. Debating the switch. For example I could never get the Ikea motion sensor to work in zha but it works just fine in Z2M. It should show right up in Z2M. 0 USB Dongle Plus P or E but i dont know witch is better and i dont understand what the differences is, has anyone tried both No, these are the first zigbee devices I have, so I just switched over to the ZHA integration for now. Multiple vendor hubs vs zigbee2mqtt (or ZHA) Recently got into HA, moving from a primarily homekit setup. To save me setting up quirks, I'ma push forward and just install z2m Now I'm working on ZHA and can't get my IKEA bulbs to pair and the Sengled bulbs report as rgb/tunable, but only seem to respond to brightness changes, not temp or rgb (this works with Z2M). . IIRC, integration with ZHA is pretty much useless out of the box (i. These are based on CC2652p2 and work with ZHA or Z2M. reReddit: Top posts of Plus is based off an older chipset but is stable for z2m and zha. The most recent update brought backup to zha. Then migrated to ZHA which was better except for the problems in the OP. Zero issues and very happy with my z2m and SkyConnect experience. I went from deconz to ZHA to Z2M and it is just faster and has a cleaner interface. Both work just fine during my week testing but cannot decide which way to go as both have Cons. i have z2m setup and my slzb-06p7 connected. Odd failure when switching from ZHA to zigbee2mqtt: ZHA works, Z2M sees (supported) devices and fails to connect to any. I’ll have to read more why the -e is better for ZHA vs. Both run on Z-Wave JS, so the conversion is just copying a few files and copy-pasting your keys. Exactly like you describe. I’ve seen mixed reviews on the Sonoff WiFi bridges, but have no first hand Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. It's always the opposite. Jan 11, 2023 · I run both Z2M and ZHA on the same system. I like the added info and flexibility I get through Z2M and I don't feel like I'm missing out in anything. So far I haven't been able to find any guides to do this, can anyone here help me out? Thanks! Nov 2, 2020 · Zigbee2MQTT vs. Both zha and z2m have a pretty decent collection of supported devices, though last I looked into it z2m seems to have a wider range of support for some of the more obscure devices out there. the z2m is pretty lean package the mqtt broker (mosquitto, for example) is also quite lean From personal experience - if ZHA works for you and supports all devices you need, I don't see a lot of benefits of moving. Both ZHA and z2m are open source. e. Search this forum or Google for ZHA vs Zigbee2MQTT and you'll learn the differences (there are literally so many treads on this). In some cases I have Zigbee devices suddenly not responding anymore in Z2M. I like the overall concept way better. Now I only have one. I vastly prefer ZIgbee2MQTT. nrfucsxc rxxlt hwc pisy zuryh wnrd akajy jenn xzmzit kbvnq